Results 1 to 5 of 5

Thread: Senate Votes

  1. #1
    Senior Member RangeBob's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2014
    Location
    Ontario
    Posts
    41,941

    Senate Votes

    I was curious how the senators voted.

    "2ndRead" is the Bill C-71 second reading Dec 11 2018.
    "Motion" is the Bill C-71 motion to adopt the Committee changes May 7 2019.

    Code:
    AFFILIATION     2ndRead    Motion     APPOINTEDBY                 COUNT(*)
    --------------- ---------- ---------- ------------------------- ----------
    Conservative    Nay        Yea        Harper, Stephen (C)               24
    Conservative    Nay        Yea        Mulroney, Brian (PC)               2
    Conservative    Nay                   Harper, Stephen (C)                4
    ISG             Yea        Abstention Harper, Stephen (C)                1
    ISG             Yea        Abstention Trudeau, Justin (Lib.)             1
    ISG             Yea        Nay        Trudeau, Justin (Lib.)            31
    ISG             Yea                   Harper, Stephen (C)                1
    ISG             Yea                   Trudeau, Justin (Lib.)             7
    ISG                        Abstention Trudeau, Justin (Lib.)             1
    ISG                        Nay        Chretien, Jean (Lib.)              2
    ISG                        Nay        Martin, Paul (Lib.)                1
    ISG                        Nay        Trudeau, Justin (Lib.)             6
    ISG                        Yea        Harper, Stephen (C)                2
    ISG                        Yea        Martin, Paul (Lib.)                1
    ISG                        Yea        Trudeau, Justin (Lib.)             1
    ISG                                   Harper, Stephen (C)                3
    Liberal         Yea        Nay        Chretien, Jean (Lib.)              3
    Liberal         Yea        Nay        Martin, Paul (Lib.)                2
    Liberal         Yea                   Chretien, Jean (Lib.)              1
    Liberal                    Nay        Chretien, Jean (Lib.)              2
    Liberal                    Nay        Martin, Paul (Lib.)                1
    Non-affiliated  Nay        Yea        Harper, Stephen (C)                1
    Non-affiliated  Nay        Yea        Trudeau, Justin (Lib.)             1
    Non-affiliated  Yea        Nay        Harper, Stephen (C)                1
    Non-affiliated  Yea        Nay        Martin, Paul (Lib.)                1
    Non-affiliated  Yea        Nay        Trudeau, Justin (Lib.)             1
    Non-affiliated                        Chretien, Jean (Lib.)              2
    Code:
    2ndRead    Motion     APPOINTEDBY                 COUNT(*)
    ---------- ---------- ------------------------- ----------
    Nay        Yea        Harper, Stephen (C)               25
    Nay        Yea        Mulroney, Brian (PC)               2
    Nay        Yea        Trudeau, Justin (Lib.)             1
    Nay                   Harper, Stephen (C)                4
    Yea        Abstention Harper, Stephen (C)                1
    Yea        Abstention Trudeau, Justin (Lib.)             1
    Yea        Nay        Chretien, Jean (Lib.)              3
    Yea        Nay        Harper, Stephen (C)                1
    Yea        Nay        Martin, Paul (Lib.)                3
    Yea        Nay        Trudeau, Justin (Lib.)            32
    Yea                   Chretien, Jean (Lib.)              1
    Yea                   Harper, Stephen (C)                1
    Yea                   Trudeau, Justin (Lib.)             7
               Abstention Trudeau, Justin (Lib.)             1
               Nay        Chretien, Jean (Lib.)              4
               Nay        Martin, Paul (Lib.)                2
               Nay        Trudeau, Justin (Lib.)             6
               Yea        Harper, Stephen (C)                2
               Yea        Martin, Paul (Lib.)                1
               Yea        Trudeau, Justin (Lib.)             1
                          Chretien, Jean (Lib.)              2
                          Harper, Stephen (C)                3
    Code:
    Motion     APPOINTEDBY                 COUNT(*)
    ---------- ------------------------- ----------
    Abstention Harper, Stephen (C)                1
    Abstention Trudeau, Justin (Lib.)             2
    Nay        Chretien, Jean (Lib.)              7
    Nay        Harper, Stephen (C)                1
    Nay        Martin, Paul (Lib.)                5
    Nay        Trudeau, Justin (Lib.)            38
    Yea        Harper, Stephen (C)               27
    Yea        Martin, Paul (Lib.)                1
    Yea        Mulroney, Brian (PC)               2
    Yea        Trudeau, Justin (Lib.)             2
               Chretien, Jean (Lib.)              3
               Harper, Stephen (C)                8
               Trudeau, Justin (Lib.)             7
    Last edited by RangeBob; 05-09-2019 at 02:17 PM.

  2. #2
    Senior Member Camo tung's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2012
    Location
    Edmonton
    Posts
    3,657
    Any idea how Senator Lynn Beyak was leaning on C-71 before she got the boot? Probably a non-issue now if what Tony Clement claims is accurate.
    "It is an absolute truism that law-abiding, armed citizens pose no threat to other law-abiding citizens."

    Ammo, camo and things that go "blammo".

  3. #3
    Senior Member RangeBob's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2014
    Location
    Ontario
    Posts
    41,941
    At 2nd reading (Dec 2018) Lynn Beyak voted Yea (bad).
    https://sencanada.ca/en/in-the-chamb...details/512680

    2nd reading votes don't really indicate a preference in the senate.

    She also voted Yea (good) to adopt the motion for the changes (May 7 2019)
    https://sencanada.ca/en/in-the-chamb...details/523884

  4. #4
    Senior Member Doug_M's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2013
    Location
    Nova Scotia
    Posts
    11,483
    She’s replied to me before and is against C-71.


    Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro
    Spread the word on petition e-2341 (Democratic process). Send people to http://oneclearvoice.ca which takes them directly to the petition.

  5. #5
    Senior Member RangeBob's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2014
    Location
    Ontario
    Posts
    41,941
    Independent Senators still most likely to vote with government, but less and less
    Jul. 25, 2018
    https://www.hilltimes.com/2018/07/25...-152033/152033

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •